Property Details

Overview

A truly unparalleled investment opportunity on Fire Island—an iconic two-story, Bayfront commercial property located right at the Cherry Grove ferry dock. Spanning over 2, 400 square feet, this rare gem offers a prime location, high visibility, and versatile income potential. The ground floor hosts three thriving rental units—including the community’s general store, an ATM kiosk, and flexible retail/office spaces—all benefitting from heavy foot traffic. Upstairs, you’ll find one of Fire Island’s most beloved dining destinations, known for its panoramic sunset views over the Great South Bay and its loyal following of locals and visitors alike. This is a turnkey, high-demand asset in one of Fire Island’s most iconic destinations—an amazing investment opportunity with steady income, prime location, and long-term growth potential.